Research: “Compulsive plague! Pain without end!” How Richard Wagner played out his Migraine in the Opera Siegfried
Kiel/London, 13.12.2013. In a paper published in the Christmas edition of the British Medical Journal (BMJ), researchers have looked at how German composer Richard Wagner’s disabling migraines and headaches influenced his operas.
As composer of the most frequently performed operas worldwide, Wagner’s medical problems have been investigated in numerous accounts and he even described his headaches and symptoms as the “main plague of his life”.
Researchers from Germany therefore wanted to show how Wagner used his suffering to compose his operas, using Siegfried as an example.
The researchers say Siegfried opens with a pulsating thumping which gradually becomes more intense until it reaches an “almost painful pulsation”. At the climax, the main character cries out “Compulsive plague! Pain without end!” which the researchers believe is a representation of a “painful, pulsating sensory migraine episode”.
Cosima Wagner (née Liszt), Richard Wagner, Franz Liszt and Hans von Wolzogen at Villa Wahnfried, Bayreuth, Upper Franconia, Germany. Richard Wagner wore a hat also in the inside, which was a standard remedy against headaches at the time. Painting by Wilhelm Beckmann 1881. Source: Richard Wagner Museum, Luzern.
In his memoirs, Wagner gives an account of the symptoms he had in September 1865, the same time he composed Siegfried. The composer openly voiced his suffering caused by the “nervous headaches” he had while composing this opera.
Wagner’s depiction of his migraines included a “scintillating, flickering, glimmering melody line with a zig-zag pattern” while a main character sings of “Loathsome light!” and “rustling and humming and blustering”. The researchers say the music has the characteristics of a typical migraine and the experimental flicker frequency gives “important clues” about the performance speed intended by Wagner.
They conclude that Richard Wagner was “severely burdened” by migraine and used his suffering creatively “letting future generations take part in his emotions and perceptions”.
In a video abstract, the researchers explain how “his pain is in the centre of his music” and question what his music would have been like had Wagner received treated for his headaches and migraines.
Research: Professor Hartmut Gobel, Kiel Headache and Pain Centre, Kiel, Germany
Tel: 0049 431 20099150
Public link to paper: http://www.bmj.com/cgi/doi/10.1136/bmj.f6952