Cambridge, MA, USA, Kiel, June 22, 2018. In the most comprehensive international collaboration to date on the molecular genetic basis of diseases of the central nervous system, the international research consortium, including scientists from the Kiel Pain Clinic, discovered genetic links between psychiatric and neurological disorders. The research group comprised more than 600 institutions worldwide. The discoveries far surpass previous knowledge on this topic. The team discovered that psychiatric disorders share extensive genetic similarities. In contrast, neurological disorders are genetically distinct. In a study published today in the journal Science, the authors describe the results of the most comprehensive dataset to date on the genetic links of brain disorders. The findings show that mental disorders have significant similarities at the molecular level that are not reflected in current diagnostic categories. The findings suggest that our understanding of the origin, diagnosis, and treatment of diseases of the central nervous system needs to be rethought.

If the genetic connections and the pattern of overlaps in the molecular-genetic basis of various diseases can be uncovered, the conditions that cause these diseases can also be better understood. Subsequently, specific mechanisms can be identified that offer targets for tailored treatments.

For the current study, international research consortia pooled their data to analyze the genetic patterns of 25 psychiatric and neurological disorders. These findings were made possible by the largest international analysis to date on this topic, which compiled all available data worldwide. The research group identified genetic overlaps using genome-wide association studies (GWAS) from 265,218 patients and 784,643 control subjects. The research project utilized data from several hundred researchers to deepen our understanding of how the brain works—a truly unprecedented undertaking.

The main finding was that there is a large overlap in the molecular basis of psychiatric disorders. This applies particularly to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), bipolar disorder, depressive episodes, and schizophrenia. The data also demonstrate a pronounced overlap in the molecular basis of anorexia nervosa, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and Tourette syndrome.

In contrast, the molecular basis of neurological diseases such as Parkinson's disease or multiple sclerosis proved to be more clearly independent. However, migraine with aura and migraine without aura were exceptions. This widespread headache disorder, which the World Health Organization (WHO) considers one of the most disabling diseases in humans, showed genetic links between attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), depressive disorders, and Tourette syndrome.

This most comprehensive study to date on the genetic links of diseases of the central nervous system provides tangible evidence of genetic foundations for psychiatric and neurological disorders. Prof. Dr. Hartmut Göbel, co-author and head physician of the Kiel Pain Clinic, comments on the findings: “The complexity of migraine as a unique neurological disorder manifests itself in significant connections with both psychological and neurological symptoms. Migraine is therefore rightly referred to as an encyclopedia of neurology. The data also demonstrate the comprehensive symptomatology of migraine. Furthermore, they explain why the risk of mental illnesses such as depression, anxiety, and personality changes is increased eightfold in migraine patients. They also highlight the shared foundations of cerebrovascular diseases and migraine, including the increased risk of stroke and cardiovascular disease.”

A key conclusion is that current diagnostic categorization of brain disorders does not accurately reflect the underlying biological reality. The diagnostic classification of these disorders may not adequately reflect the mechanisms by which these disorders arise within the central nervous system and cause overlapping symptoms.

Further elucidation of these genetic relationships can lead to the differentiation of new clinical disease entities and enable more precise development of new treatment methods as well as the selection of patients for effective treatments. A limited association was found for comorbidity between migraine with aura and ischemic stroke. The subtypes of migraine, migraine without aura and migraine with aura, also showed substantial genetic associations. For neurological diseases, it became clear that Alzheimer's disease, intracerebral hemorrhage, ischemic stroke, and migraine exhibited significant negative genetic associations with cognitive variables.

 

Source: Science 22 Jun 2018:Vol. 360, Issue 6395, eaap8757, DOI: 10.1126/science.aap8757

Analysis of shared heritability in common disorders of the brain: By The Brainstorm Consortium
, Verneri Anttila , Brendan Bulik-Sullivan , Hilary K. Finucane , Raymond K. Walters , Jose Bras , Laramie Duncan , Valentina Escott-Price , Guido J. Falcone , Padhraig Gormley , Rainer Malik , Nikolaos A. Patsopoulos , Stephan Ripke , Zhi Wei , Dongmei Yu , Phil H. Lee , Patrick Turley , Benjamin Grenier-Boley , Vincent Chouraki , Yoichiro Kamatani , Claudine Berr , Luc Letenneur , Didier Hannequin , Philippe Amouyel , Anne Boland , Jean-François Deleuze , Emmanuelle Duron , Badri N. Vardarajan , Christiane Reitz , Alison M. Goate , Matthew J. Huentelman , M. Ilyas Kamboh , Eric B. Larson , Ekaterina Rogaeva , Peter St George-Hyslop , Hakon Hakonarson , Walter A. Kukull , Lindsay A. Farrer , Lisa L. Barnes , Thomas G. Beach , F. Yesim Demirci , Elizabeth Head , Christine M. Hulette , Gregory A. Jicha , John SK Kauwe , Jeffrey A. Kaye , James B. Leverenz , Allan I. Levey , Andrew P. Lieberman , Vernon S. Pankratz , Wayne W. Poon , Joseph F. Quinn , Andrew J. Saykin , Lon S. Schneider , Amanda G. Smith , Joshua A. Sonnen , Robert A. Stern , Vivianna M. Van Deerlin , Linda J. Van Eldik , Denise Harold , Giancarlo Russo , David C. Rubinszstein , Anthony Bayer , Magda Tsolaki , Petra Proitsi , Nick C. Fox , Harald Hampel , Michael J. Owen , Simon Mead , Peter Passmore , Kevin Morgan , Markus M. Nöthen , Martin Rossor , Michelle K. Lupton , Per Hoffmann , Johannes Kornhuber , Brian Lawlor , Andrew McQuillin , Ammar Al-Chalabi , Joshua C Bis , Agustin Ruiz , Mercè Boada , Sudha Seshadri , Alexa Beiser , Kenneth Rice , Sven J. van der Lee , Philip L. De Jager , Daniel H. Geschwind , Matthias Riemenschneider , Steffi Riedel-Heller , Jerome I Rotter , Gerhard Ransmayr , Bradley T. Hyman , Carlos Cruchaga , Montserrat Alegret , Bendik Winsvold , Priit Palta , Kai-How Farh , Ester Cuenca-Leon , Nicholas Furlotte , Tobias Kurth , Lannie Ligthart , Gisela M. Terwindt , Tobias Freilinger , Caroline Ran , Scott D. Gordon , Guntram Borck , Hieab HH Adams , Terho Lehtimäki , Juho Wedenoja , Julie E. Buring , Markus Schürks , Maria Hrafnsdottir , Jouke-Jan Hottenga , Brenda Penninx , Ville Artto , Mari Kaunisto , Salli Vepsäläinen , Nicholas G. Martin , Grant W. Montgomery , Mitja I. Kurki , Eija Hämäläinen , Hailiang Huang , Jie Huang , Cynthia Sandor , Caleb Webber , Bertram Muller-Myhsok , Stefan Schreiber , Veikko Salomaa , Elizabeth Loehrer , Hartmut Göbel , Alfons Macaya , Patricia Pozo-Rosich , Thomas Hansen , Thomas Werge , Jaakko Kaprio , Andres Metspalu , Christian Kubisch , Michel D. Ferrari , Andrea C. Belin , Arn MJM van den Maagdenberg , John-Anker Zwart , Dorret Boomsma , Nicholas Eriksson , Jes Olesen , Daniel I. Chasman , Dale R. Nyholt , Andreja Avbersek , Larry Baum , Samuel Berkovic , Jonathan Bradfield , Russell Buono , Claudia B. Catarino , Patrick Cossette , Peter De Jonghe , Chantal Depondt , Dennis Dlugos , Thomas N. Ferraro , Jacqueline French , Helle Hjalgrim , Jennifer Jamnadas-Khoda , Reetta Kälviäinen , Wolfram S. Kunz , Holger Lerche , Costin Leu , Dick Lindhout , Warren Lo , Daniel Lowenstein , Mark McCormack , Rikke S. Møller , Anne Molloy , Ping-Wing Ng , Karen Oliver , Michael Privitera , Rodney Radtke , Ann-Kathrin Ruppert , Thomas Sander , Steven Schachter , Christoph Schankin , Ingrid Scheffer , Susanne Schoch , Sanjay M. Sisodiya , Philip Smith , Michael Sperling , Pasquale Striano , Rainer Surges , G. Neil Thomas , Frank Visscher , Christopher D. Whelan , Federico Zara , Erin L. Heinzen , Anthony Marson , Felicitas Becker , Hans Stroink , Fritz Zimprich , Thomas Gasser , Raphael Gibbs , Peter Heutink , Maria Martinez , Huw R. Morris , Manu Sharma , Mina Ryten , Kin Y. Mok , Sara Pulit , Steve Bevan , Elizabeth Holliday , John Attia , Thomas Battey , Giorgio Boncoraglio , Vincent Thijs , Wei-Min Chen , Braxton Mitchell , Peter Rothwell , Pankaj Sharma , Cathie Sudlow , Astrid Vicente , Hugh Markus , Christina Kourkoulis , Joana Pera , Miriam Raffeld , Scott Silliman , Vesna Boraska Perica , Laura M. Thornton , Laura M. Huckins , N. William Rayner , Cathryn M. Lewis , Monica Gratacos , Filip Rybakowski , Anna Keski-Rahkonen , Anu Raevuori , James I. Hudson , Ted Reichborn-Kjennerud , Palmiero Monteleone , Andreas Karwautz , Katrin Mannik , Jessica H. Baker , Julie K. O'Toole , Sara E. Trace , Oliver SP Davis , Sietske G. Helder , Stefan Ehrlich , Beate Herpertz-Dahlmann , Unna N. Danner , Annemarie A. van Elburg , Maurizio Clementi , Monica Forzan , Elisa Docampo , Jolanta Lissowska , Joanna Hauser , Alfonso Tortorella , Mario Maj , Fragiskos Gonidakis , Konstantinos Tziouvas , Hana Papezova , Zeynep Yilmaz , Gudrun Wagner , Sarah Cohen-Woods , Stefan Herms , Antonio Julià , Raquel Rabionet , Danielle M. Dick , Samuli Ripatti , Ole A. Andreassen , Thomas Espeseth , Astri J. Lundervold , Vidar M. Steen , Dalila Pinto , Stephen W. Scherer , Harald Aschauer , Alexandra Schosser , Lars Alfredsson , Leonid Padyukov , Katherine A. Halmi , James Mitchell , Michael Strober , Andrew W. Bergen , Walter Kaye , Jin Peng Szatkiewicz , Bru Cormand , Josep Antoni Ramos-Quiroga , Cristina Sánchez-Mora , Marta Ribasés , Miguel Casas , Amaia Hervas , Maria Jesús Arranz , Jan Haavik , Tetyana Zayats , Stefan Johansson , Nigel Williams , Astrid Dempfle , Aribert Rothenberger , Jonna Kuntsi , Robert D. Oades , Tobias Banaschewski , Barbara Franke , Jan K. Buitelaar , Alejandro Arias Vasquez , Alysa E. Doyle , Andreas Reif , Klaus-Peter Lesch , Christine Freitag , Olga Rivero , Haukur Palmason , Marcel Romanos , Kate Langley , Marcella Rietschel , Stephanie H. Witt , Soeren Dalsgaard , Anders D. Børglum , Irwin Waldman , Beth Wilmot , Nikolas Molly , Claiton HD Bau , Jennifer Crosbie , Russell Schachar , Sandra K. Loo , James J. McGough , Eugenio H. Grevet , Sarah E. Medland , Elise Robinson , Lauren A. Weiss , Elena Bacchelli , Anthony Bailey , Vanessa Bal , Agatino Battaglia , Catalina Betancur , Patrick Bolton , Rita Cantor , Patrícia Celestino-Soper , Geraldine Dawson , Silvia De Rubeis , Frederico Duque , Andrew Green , Sabine M. Klauck , Marion Leboyer , Pat Levitt , Elena Maestrini , Shrikant Mane , Daniel Moreno-De-Luca , Jeremy Parr , Regina Regan , Abraham Reichenberg , Sven Sandin , Jacob Vorstman , Thomas Wassink , Ellen Wijsman , Edwin Cook , Susan Santangelo , Richard Delorme , Bernadette Rogé , Tiago Magalhaes , Dan Arking , Thomas G. Schulze , Robert C. Thompson , Jana Strohmaier , Keith Matthews , Ingrid Melle , Derek Morris , Douglas Blackwood , Andrew McIntosh , Sarah E. Bergen , Martin Schalling , Stéphane Jamain , Anna Maaser , Sascha B. Fischer , Céline S. Reinbold , Janice M. Fullerton , José Guzman-Parra , Fermin Mayoral , Peter R. Schofield , Sven Cichon , Thomas W. Mühleisen , Franziska Degenhardt , Johannes Schumacher , Michael Bauer , Philip B. Mitchell , Elliot S. Gershon , John Rice , James B. Potash , Peter P. Zandi , Nick Craddock , I. Nicol Ferrier , Martin Alda , Guy A. Rouleau , Gustavo Turecki , Roel Ophoff , Carlos Pato , Adebayo Anjorin , Eli Stahl , Markus Leber , Piotr M. Czerski , Cristiana Cruceanu , Ian R. Jones , Danielle Posthuma , Till FM Andlauer , Andreas J. Forstner , Fabian Streit , Bernhard T. Baune , Tracy Air , Grant Sinnamon , Naomi R. Wray , Donald J. MacIntyre , David Porteous , Georg Homuth , Margarita Rivera , Jakob Grove , Christel M. Middeldorp , Ian Hickie , Michele Pergadia , Divya Mehta , Johannes H. Smit , Rick Jansen , Eco de Geus , Erin Dunn , Qingqin S. Li , Matthias Nauck , Robert A. Schoevers , Aartjan TF Beekman , James A. Knowles , Alexander Viktorin , Paul Arnold , Cathy L. Barr , Gabriel Bedoya-Berrio , O. Joseph Bienvenu , Helena Brentani , Christie Burton , Beatriz Camarena , Carolina Cappi , Danielle Cath , Maria Cavallini , Daniele Cusi , Sabrina Darrow , Damiaan Denys , Eske M. Derks , Andrea Dietrich , Thomas Fernandez , Martijn Figee , Nelson Freimer , Gloria Gerber , Marco Grados , Erica Greenberg , Gregory L. Hanna , Andreas Hartmann , Matthew E. Hirschtritt , Pieter J. Hoekstra , Alden Huang , Chaim Huyser , Cornelia Illmann , Michael Jenike , Samuel Kuperman , Bennett Leventhal , Christine Lochner , Gholson J. Lyon , Fabio Macciardi , Marcos Madruga-Garrido , Irene A. Malaty , Athanasios Maras , Lauren McGrath , Eurípedes C. Miguel , Pablo Mir , Gerald Nestadt , Humberto Nicolini , Michael S. Okun , Andrew Pakstis , Peristera Paschou , John Piacentini , Christopher Pittenger , Kerstin Plessen , Vasily Ramensky , Eliana M. Ramos , Victor Reus , Margaret A. Richter , Mark A. Riddle , Mary M. Robertson , Veit Roessner , Maria Rosário , Jack F. Samuels , Paul Sandor , Dan J. Stein , Fotis Tsetsos , Filip Van Nieuwerburgh , Sarah Weatherall , Jens R. Wendland , Tomasz Wolanczyk , Yulia Worbe , Gwyneth Zai , Fernando S. Goes , Nicole McLaughlin , Paul S. Nestadt , Hans-Jorgen Grabe , Christel Depienne , Anuar Konkashbaev , Nuria Lanzagorta , Ana Valencia-Duarte , Elvira Bramon , Nancy Buccola , Wiepke Cahn , Murray Cairns , Siow A. Chong , David Cohen , Benedicto Crespo-Facorro , James Crowley , Michael Davidson , Lynn DeLisi , Timothy Dinan , Gary Donohoe , Elodie Drapeau , Jubao Duan , Lieuwe Haan , David Hougaard , Sena Karachanak-Yankova , Andrey Khrunin , Janis Klovins , Vaidutis Kučinskas , Jimmy Lee Chee Keong , Svetlana Limborska , Carmel Loughland , Jouko Lönnqvist , Brion Maher , Manuel Mattheisen , Colm McDonald , Kieran C Murphy , Igor Nenadic , Jim van Os , Christos Pantelis , Michele Pato , Tracey Petryshen , Digby Quested , Panos Roussos , Alan R. Sanders , Ulrich Schall , Sibylle G. Schwab , Kang Sim , Hon-Cheong So , Elisabeth Stögmann , Mythily Subramaniam , Draga Toncheva , John Waddington , James Walters , Mark Weiser , Wei Cheng , Robert Cloninger , David Curtis , Pablo V. Gejman , Frans Henskens , Morten Mattingsdal , Sang-Yun Oh , Rodney Scott , Bradley Webb , Gerome Breen , Claire Churchhouse , Cynthia M. Bulik , Mark Daly , Martin Dichgans , Stephen V. Faraone , Rita Guerreiro , Peter Holmans , Kenneth S. Kendler , Bobby Koeleman , Carol A. Mathews , Alkes Price , Jeremiah Scharf , Pamela Sklar , Julie Williams , Nicholas W. Wood , Chris Cotsapas , Aarno Palotie , Jordan W. Smoller , Patrick Sullivan , Jonathan Rosand , Aiden Corvin , Benjamin M. Neale Science 22 Jun 2018:Vol. 360, Issue 6395, eaap8757, DOI: 10.1126/science.aap8757